[Fergaiste]

my player ratings are

vds 7 Apart from that one shaky moment at the start when evra cleared, simply accomplished as we come to expect from the dutch master
hargo 7 top class player who has had a brilliant albeit injury blighted season. Mr reliable imo wherever he plays.
evra 8 magnificent yet again. If he keeps this up over the next few seasons he will be spoken of in the same breath as Irwin as united's greatest ever full back.
Rio 7 Tough afternoon against Ashton but stuck to his task well. goal was more Brown's fault for putting him into trouble but anyway the finish was just sublime
Wes 7 The goal notwithstanding still a composed display from the local lad.
Nani 5 The bloke obviously has a bit of growing up to do . The sending off just capped off a week where for all his obvious potential and self belief he needs to think of the team before he does childish things things like that headbutting an opponent or trying to score from 40 yrds when better options are on. Its also un-united to be unsportmanslike the way he tried to get Neill the red card.

Scholes 8 Different class in terms of keeping possesssion and passing range. A truly great player.
carrick 6.5 Although he got the decisive goal still not convinced. seems to lack confidence at th moment as even after scoring he chose the wrong option in passing a couple of times when he should have went for goal himself.
Park 7 typically industrious performance from the Korean.now first choice instead of giggs which surprised me but fully merited.
Ronaldo 8 apart from a few times when he tried to be too extravagant and gave the ball away cheaply he was excellent with the couple of goals expertly taken. now can we see a similar performance in moscow please.
Tevez 8.5 MY mom for his simply awesome performance.

Subs

Giggs 7 Thought he looked a lot sharper than he has done for a while perhaps because he knows he can no longer command a first team place even once a week. Then he has been under threat from sharpe/blomqvis among others and seen them all off. He knows he has to earn charlton's record so hopefully a return to form is in the offing.

O'Shea 6 ok apart from once stupid back pass that almost cost us

fletcher 6 not on very long but tidy and willing as ever