Quote:
| Originally Posted by Keano4taoiseach A bit harsh Scott in my opinion.
He came back from a long term injury and was lacking match fitness at first and was a bit rusty but he has played well in the last few games and against Barca he was superb, in both legs.
Carrick has been inconsistent. He was poor in both legs against Barca and went missing in many a league game this season. |
I'm not saying if their good or bad. Scholes has been fantastic against Fulham, Barca and Liverpool. I though he was poor against Tottenham away, Arsenal home and Pompy at home by his standards. Someone like Giggs has been consistently poor imo.
Carrick has been a bit off the boil in the last couple of games, but over the seaon he hasn't been exceptional or poor, about a 7 out of 10 performance each game. To re-iterate, I'm not saying the inconsistent players are worse. I'm judging them by their standards.
