So who do we pick ?

[charles]

Carrick,Scholes,Hargeaves,Anderson,Fletcher,O shea

Which two from that lot do we have in centre of midfield ???

[reddwarf]

Depends on the opposition. Do you have a particular game in mind or are you asking who we think our best pairing is?

If so, I'd say Hargreaves and Scholes.

[Lawbreaker1944]

I want there M. Carrick, P. Scholes, O. Hargeaves, Anderson, D. Fletcher and J. O'Shea. All of them!

So let's change football rules!!!


Otherwise:

nowadays P. Scholes and O. Hargreaves

in 2 years time M. Carrick and J. O'Shea

in 5 years time M. Carrick and Anderson

...

in 20 years time Scholes's kid and O. Hargreaves's kid

[rhys_utd]

hargreaveas and scholes and carrick next in line

[rydersonthestorm]

No way john o shea he is a back up player and the same with fletcher, hargreaves (carrick back up) scholes (anderson back up)

[charles]

No way john o shea he is a back up player and the same with fletcher, hargreaves (carrick back up) scholes (anderson back up)



Did you ever see the guy in your avatar play...????

[rydersonthestorm]

Obviously not live becuase i am 24, but i have seen plenty of old games and the only guy at the time that could compare with mr edwards was john charles.

[rooneyNo10]

Hargo and scolesy with carrick and anderson next in line incase of injuries and easier opposition.

[Jazz 16]

Hargo and scolesy with carrick and anderson next in line incase of injuries and easier opposition.
Id go along with that too. Rotation and resting players will come into it too. Id prefer OH in there against the better teams going forward but Carrick gets the attack going quicker than OH and is a better passer of the ball. Anderson looks promising and will get a few chances here and there. When Schloles is back he will be straight in the team.

[Wazza1989]

hargreaves & scholes

[Keano4taoiseach]

Id go along with that too. Rotation and resting players will come into it too. Id prefer OH in there against the better teams going forward but Carrick gets the attack going quicker than OH and is a better passer of the ball. Anderson looks promising and will get a few chances here and there. When Schloles is back he will be straight in the team.




that's a bit of an understatement....:D


That's the way the midfield should be though...with Ronny and Nani/Giggs flanking them...

[Teveth_32]

Carrick and scholes.

[andycole9]

No way john o shea he is a back up player and the same with fletcher, hargreaves (carrick back up) scholes (anderson back up)
i agree, but i also think carrick could play the scholes role with no problem what so ever :)

that's a bit of an understatement....:D


That's the way the midfield should be though...with Ronny and Nani/Giggs flanking them...
lol we already have a debate going about that one don't start it here aswell :D

[rydersonthestorm]

I think carrick could play the scholes role but i think it would depend on the team united where playing against and if it was home or away. I think against a weak side at home carrick and hargreaves would be a little bit defensive for my liking.

[steps_3314]

thats easy...scholes (when he's fit) and hargreaves..until scholes is fit then id say hargreaves and anderson..thought they were great on saturday..fletcher and o'shea just dont do it for me..great servants and all but useful as subs these days i think