What Is Our Best Starting Eleven ?

[Drew9]

I believe it is most difficault to pick the central midfeild what do you think ?

[man.utd.singh]

.................Van Der Sar...................
.....Nev.....Ferdi.........Vidic....Evra...
.Ronaldo..Hargo....Scholes....Giggs
..............Tevez.......Roony..............

I chose Scholes and Hargo because they can both attack but there defence attributes are awesome.

And with Nani, Anderson and carric on the bench we can change tactics dramatically to break through defences using, speed, tactics and deadly assists.

[Ignatius]

.................Van Der Sar...................
.....Nev.....Ferdi.........Vidic....Evra...
.Ronaldo..Hargo....Scholes....Giggs
..............Tevez.......Roony..............

I chose Scholes and Hargo because they can both attack but there defence attributes are awesome.

And with Nani, Anderson and carric on the bench we can change tactics dramatically to break through defences using, speed, tactics and deadly assists.

Your smart:p

[Keano!]

Now......

-----------------------------------Van Der Sar-------------------------------------
-
--Neville (C)----------------Ferdinand----------Vidic-----------------------Evra----
-
--Ronaldo-------------Scholes--------------Carrick------------------Giggs----
-
-------------------------Rooney----------------------------------------------------
-
-----------------------------------------------Tevez--------------------------------

Bench: Kusczazk, O'Shea, Anderson, Hargreaves, Fletcher

[-zuco-]

Now......

-----------------------------------Van Der Sar-------------------------------------
-
--Neville (C)----------------Ferdinand----------Vidic-----------------------Evra----
-
--Ronaldo-------------Scholes--------------Carrick------------------Giggs----
-
-------------------------Rooney----------------------------------------------------
-
-----------------------------------------------Tevez--------------------------------

Bench: Kusczazk, O'Shea, Anderson, Hargreaves, Fletcher

Where's Nani?

man.utd.singh: Scholes couldn't defend if his life depended on it.

[Manchester Boy_nWo]

VDS

G.Neville(C) Ferdinand Vidic Evra

Ronaldo Scholes Anderson Giggs

Rooney Tevez

SUBS:Kuszczak, Brown, Carrick, Anderson, Saha

[Keano!]

Where's Nani?

man.utd.singh: Scholes couldn't defend if his life depended on it.

Ye, I know but I couldn't decide on Nani or Anderson and lately, Nani seems to go for goal on his own too much. Not enough of a team player, "yet". He'll be like Ronny........thinks he's knows it all but will be moulded into something special IMO

[man.utd.singh]

Where's Nani?

man.utd.singh: Scholes couldn't defend if his life depended on it.

Hey, scholes can defend, hes just a milli second late sometimes. But he still can play as a great dmc.

[Northern Ireland MUFC]

VDS

G.Neville(C) Ferdinand Vidic Evra

Ronaldo Scholes Anderson Giggs

Rooney Tevez

SUBS:Kuszczak, Brown, Carrick, Anderson, Saha


We have two Anderson's ?

[Keano4taoiseach]

Probably not the 11 that started today anyway ;)

[Ignatius]

Hehe :D

[haggler]

Where's Nani?

man.utd.singh: Scholes couldn't defend if his life depended on it.on the plane back to portugal quick smart unless he improves and quickly . why do so many rate nani ? headless chicken that cant cross or tackle and doesnt know his arse from his elbow

[weaste red]

Van der Sar
Neville
Ferdinand
Vidic
Evra
Ronaldo
Scholes
Hargreaves
Giggs
Rooney
Tevez

[Fergaiste]

van der sar

neville vidic ferdinand evra

park scholes hargreaves ronaldo

rooney tevez

I would leave out Giggs not just based on today's performance but he just has not been at the races this season. The likes of Nani and anderson have great potential therefore I would not hammer them based on the derby match. I just felt Ferguson got the starting line up wrong in that a derby match suits more irish or British type players who are used to frenetic matches like derby games in the premiership.

Park I think though deserves to be in the team more often given his attitude, workrate and end product.

[Jazz 16]

Im surprised that most people have left Anderson and Nani out giving the amount some on here have bigged them up. Nani for me has not impressed much. haggler phrased it nicely above lol

Id still stick with the old guard for now and introduce the likes of Park, Carrick and Anderson off the bench. We need Hargreaves for his destructive qualities.

VDS

G.Neville(C) Ferdinand Vidic Evra

Ronaldo Scholes Anderson Giggs

Rooney Tevez

[man.utd.singh]

on the plane back to portugal quick smart unless he improves and quickly . why do so many rate nani ? headless chicken that cant cross or tackle and doesnt know his arse from his elbow

thats what people thought of ronaldo when he came to town.

[Because I'm DC]

VDS

Neville-Ferdinand-Vidic-Evra

Ronaldo-Carrick-Scholes-Giggs

Rooney-Tevez


Tough one to decide who partners Scholes in the centre of midfield but Anderson needs another season before hes a regular, although he's fast becoming one of my favourite players, and I just prefer Carrick to Hargreaves because hes got a better passing range and hes calmer, and more skillfull on the ball.

[United_OG]

vds

brown rio vidic evra

ronaldo hargo
anderson giggs/nani

rooney tevez

[haggler]

thats what people thought of ronaldo when he came to town.if nani improves in the same way ronnie did i will be back on to eat humble pie . he looks like the baby nobody expected to survive the runt of the litter if you will . if hed been a elephant seal his ma would have smothered him at birth . ronaldo nicked all his free school milk

[Red Devil]

I have not yet seen the starting eleven for yesterday, but I do question Fergie's judgement. The best starting eleven for united is the best fittest eleven he has available - end of. As far as I can see, Fergie cost us the game.

[SolskjaertheLegend]

If everyones 100% fit and on-form then

VDS

Neville - Rio - Vidic - Evra

Ronaldo - Hargreaves - Scholes - Giggs

Tevez - Rooney

Great team, IMO
Good GK
Strong Defence
Goals, Creativity in the midfield with Ronaldo, Scholes & Giggs
Energy & good protection for the defence with Hargreaves
Upront, two forwards that will fight for everything and can finish.

---

But at the moment, id go with

VDS

Bown - Rio - Vidic - Evra

Ronaldo - Hargreaves - Anderson - Park

Tevez - Rooney

Left wing position? Nani isnt ready for the 1st team yet IMO, Giggs is very off-form, so that really leaves only Park. He'll add more energy to the midfield, and always does his job well for us.
Anderson is doing great for us, whereas Scholes has just come back from a lengthy injury.

[conor myles]

I agree with you zuco dats our best eleven