Who is the greatest United ever

[RichardsReds]

Sir Matt Busby, Sir Alex Ferguson, Ryan Giggs, Bobby Charlton, George Best, Eric Cantona, Paul Parker, Byran Robson, Christiano Ronaldo?

Let's have yours.

Mine is Ryan Giggs!

[tonnas]

Player = best
manager = saf

[IpDipDoo]

The greatest United ever is Bobby Charlton.

[RoxiiUtd]

Sir Alex Ferguson, without him many talents wouldn't have been recognized, and our history wouldn't have been as decorated.

[RedForceRising]

Skill = Ronaldo
Legend = Best
My Fave = Giggsy
Manager = Sir Alex

[Because I'm DC]

Sir Alex. He's simply not comparable to the others mentioned in terms of what he's acheived and what he's brought to the club.

[squig_mufc]

player - well in my lifetime i would say giggs or keane. too young to ever see charlton or best, but my dad says charlton is the greatest ever to don a united shirt

manager - SAF. enough said

[Treble_99]

Manager - SAF
Player - Giggs(in my lifetime) overall - Sir Bobby Charlton

[AidanNelson2009]

Manager = Sir Alex Ferguson

Greatest Player = (I would have said Ronaldo, but IMO he has not been at United long enough to be the greatest United player) so for me it's Ryan Giggs.

[peterswellman]

Sir Matt Busby without him we wouldn't be the club we are today. Same could be said from SAF but Busby came before him and if he never arrived SAF might never have had the chance.

[IpDipDoo]

Sir Matt Busby without him we wouldn't be the club we are today. Same could be said from SAF but Busby came before him and if he never arrived SAF might never have had the chance.

Sir Matt is definatly a good call but i've gotta stick with Sir Bobby because he's just such a nice guy, even the Dippers like him.

[daveskimufc]

best united player ever........SCHOLESY

[Stephen]

Top 5:

Busby
Ferguson
Murphy
Giggs
Charlton

I'm not going to put them in order. Too hard

[manutd004]

Sir Matt Busby without him we wouldn't be the club we are today. Same could be said from SAF but Busby came before him and if he never arrived SAF might never have had the chance.

That's exactly what I think. It might be hard on Sir Alex, but Busby was the one with the vision to build the club.

I think it's far too hard and harsh to pick one name really, and Sir Alex, Bobby Charlton, Ryan Giggs should also be mentioned as well as others.

[NateR]

Sir Matt.

[Richie]

Greatest United ever? Manchester!

[babysenorita]

Sir Matt Busby...he started it...sir alex continue it..

[united forever]

Manager: Sir Alex Ferguson

Player:Ryan Giggs( in my lifetime i suppose overall it might be Best)

[TheManc]

Talent - Best
Overall contribution - Sir Bobby Charlton
Impact - Cantona

Best manager - Sir Matt Busby.


Greatest: Charlton.

Edwards is the wild card. We know he would have been up there with the best, but we don't have proof.

For me Giggs is a step below Charlton. They played a similar amount of games (Charlton started more), and while Giggs has won more, Charlton is the face of the club as he has been through so much. He was also one of the best players of all time. Giggs was never the main man.

[Majestic United]

I'm going to put a slightly different spin on this thread if you don't mind - the 10 most important men in the history of United:

1. SAF
2. Matt Busby
3. Bobby Charlton
4. James Gibson
5. Eric Cantona
6. George Best
7. Ryan Giggs
8. Roy Keane
9. Denis Law
10. Peter Schmeichel

The game is all about opinions, and no doubt thousands will disagree with mine.