Player ratings versus Hull

[Davey]

Pig: 6

Rafael: 6.5
Brown: 7
Vidic: 7.5
Evra: 6

Valencia: 5.5
Carrick: 6.5
Fletcher: 7
Giggs: 5

Berbatov: 6
Rooney: 8.5

You can laugh but he's been shit lately mate. Passing awful, crossing is absolutely terrible and very indecisive.

[Sownak27]

that's not what bbc sports say

bbc..

Darren Fletcher swung in a near-post cross from the right flank, Giggs deflected it to Rooney, and the lurking England man prodded home from close-range.

though the official utd site says giggs missed it.

watched the goal 4 times now and it does look like there's a slight defelection, as in slow motion the ball changes direction slightly.

who's assist ? i'd say it was fletch really.

The Premier League's official match report has it as Fletch's as there is no mention of Giggs:

Pressure finally paid off as Hull failed to clear a Fletcher cross and Rooney tapped in from close range during two minutes of stoppage time.

[NoxiousD]

Promise
On my lovely new flat screen.
REVISED RESULTS:
Carrick 6.5
Rooney 7
happy?

You don't get to revise, your first ratings were atrocious, Carrick better than Rafael? Rafael made ONE mistake all game, and that was more down to Rooneys error...

[Loublaze]

I wonder wtf Rooney was thinking with that play man

[sunny]

Okay, okay.
Dreadful error, I can't help it, I'm an escaped lunatic with a fixatation for Carrick.

[sunny]

I wonder wtf Rooney was thinking with that play man

[peterswellman]

Kuszczak -7

Rafael - 5.5
Brown -6
Vidic - 6.5
Evra - 5

Valencia - 5
Carrick -1
Fletcher -5.5
Giggs -5

Rooney -8
Berbatov - 5



Park -
Obertan -

[Keano!]

Kuszczak - 7

Rafael - 7.5
Brown - 7.5
Vidic - 7.5
Evra - 7

Valencia - 6
Carrick - 6.5
Fletcher - 8
Giggs - 6.5

Rooney - 8.5
Berbatov - 6



Park -
Obertan -

[TheFutureIsAnderson]

Kuszczak - 8 - Very impressed with him. Some good saves and held on to some tricky shots.

Rafael - 7.5 - Good display, shame he gave away pen
Brown - 6.0 - Often looked shaky, should have given away a pen. The weak link in an otherwise strong defense
Vidic - 7.5 - Solid performance
Evra - 6.5 - Not his best performance but he sets the standard high

Valencia - 4.5 - Very poor, wasteful and ineffective
Carrick - He played?
Fletcher - 7.0 - Good cross for the goal, worked hard.
Giggs - 5 - Offered very little although we still look so much more dangerous with him in the team

Rooney - 9 - Pure class, made a bad mistake but you just knew he'd make up for it creating two goals to add to his earlier strike. Very impressive and good to see him looking like the boy wonder we fell in love with. He won us the game in the end.
Berbatov - 4 - Terrible. Utter ******* *****. Offers nothing and slows everything down. Excpecting Rooney to punch him the ******* head pretty soon. His little tap in gets him up 1 but he can go **** himself the useless waste of space. Hope he gets kidnapped again. Dick.



Park - 7 - Lively, provided an upgrade
Obertan - Not on long enough, so he gets the Micahel Carrick treatment

[razz1979]

Kuszczak - 7

Rafael - 5
Brown - 5
Vidic - 5.5
Evra - 6

Valencia - 5
Carrick - 5
Fletcher - 5
Giggs - 5

Rooney - 5
Berbatov - 5



Park - 5
Obertan - 5

Basically we were lucky to win and it was a poor performance, lets hope for better against Wigan

[peterswellman]

Kuszczak - 7

Rafael - 5
Brown - 5
Vidic - 5.5
Evra - 6

Valencia - 5
Carrick - 5
Fletcher - 5
Giggs - 5

Rooney - 5
Berbatov - 5



Park - 5
Obertan - 5

Basically we were lucky to win and it was a poor performance, lets hope for better against Wigan

Rooney a 5? What the hell is wrong with you?

[andersons_left_foot]

Kuszczak - 7 Made a few good saves and was strong in goal.

Rafael - 6 Did well, but couldnt really do much about the penalty.
Brown - 6 Sold at the back although got lucky with his tackle in the first half.
Vidic - 7 Sold as ever, im so happy to have him back
Evra - 7 Was great as normal

Valencia - 6 Didnt really do to much, was well marked.
Carrick - 5 Did his job although i dont think he gives to much to our team
Fletcher - 8 Impressive as ever gave us so much in the midfield, happy to have him back there.
Giggs - 6 I think hes better in the centre than on the wing, but got in the right places at the right time.

Rooney - 9 Although e made a awful error he more than made up for it, gave 100% great performance.
Berbatov - 5 Slowed play up is more of a hinderance to us than a help, easy tap in also.



Park - 6 Didnt really get long enough, but would have scored if it were not for the OG
Obertan - 1 Didnt get long enough.

Glad we got back to winning and scoring ways, i still feels we need another front man.

[sunny]

Rooney a 5? What the hell is wrong with you?

Rooney was easily one of the worst players on the pitch in the first half.

[Owenzy]

Rooney was easily one of the worst players on the pitch in the first half.

But a goal and two assists takes you from a 5 to an 8.5! He showed great determination after his mistake. He wasn't that bad in the 1st half, he was the only player working the goalkeeper!

[sunny]

But a goal and two assists takes you from a 5 to an 8.5! He showed great determination after his mistake. He wasn't that bad in the 1st half, he was the only player working the goalkeeper!

Yes, but his passing was abismal! Honestly, he gave the ball away too many times plus that mistake was so awful! I gave him a 7 I think.

[Owenzy]

Yes, but his passing was abismal! Honestly, he gave the ball away too many times plus that mistake was so awful! I gave him a 7 I think.

That's because he's always looking for a killer pass. I don't mind players who try to be productive, far too many of our players play square passes and are afraid to take risks.

[peterswellman]

Rooney was easily one of the worst players on the pitch in the first half.

Football matches only last 45 iirc.

[sunny]

Okay, I'm not bashing Rooney but I'm saying that his firsthalf he played pretty poorly, his second half he was much better.

[sunny]

Football matches only last 45 iirc.

First half rooney rating - 4.5
Second half Rooney rating - 8.5

[hdcantona]

Kuszczak - 6

Rafael - 6.5
Brown - 6.5
Vidic - 7
Evra - 7

Valencia - 5
Carrick - 6
Fletcher - 7
Giggs - 5.5

Rooney - 7.5 MOTM (5.5 +1 goal (1 point) + 2 assists (1 point) - goal costing error (1 point)
Berbatov - 7 (6 + 1 goal (1 point))



Park - 5.5
Obertan -5