[RoyKeaneIsMagic]

Please leave comments below about your opinion on the matter

In my honest opinion i feel it is too early to tell but i think the best has to be roy keane

[Red Devil]

give us a break! He has not had a chance to prove anything yet, ask me again in 5 years. Until then only two deserve the "great" mantle, Best & Cantona.

[ImNew2ThisWebsite]

rite he is a really good player but he hasnt been at old traffort long enough to be called the best and of course i think he has a long way to go to even equal with the likes of cantana, best, robson or even keane!!!!

[manutdc]

Fantastic player. The best ever? He's still got to prove that. Can he be the best ever? Yes.

[Loki]

Could potentially be but the jury is still out. Too many true greats to live up to

Let's put it this way...Rooney's going to be one of United's all-time great's..no question..

[azer1990]

ROONEY will be there 1 day but no yet .There are many greats such as KING CANTONA, THE GREAT DANE SCHMEICHLE and THE BEST GEORGE BEST and CAOTAIN KEANE there ares ome nay greats we can never foget about but 1 day ROONEY WILL BE WITH THEM and i would like 2 say so wud OLE GUNNAR AND GIGGS AND SCHOLES

No Offence But We Can Never Forget The Greatest Keeper To Touch The Grass Of Old Trafford The Great Dane Peter Schmeichle