Modern Day 1-player-per-club (Premiership only) draft: Discussion only thread.

By playing just over 50% of the game. Dawson is more important to Spurs these days than King.

If both are fit, King is better then Smalling, he's up there with terry too for that matter...When he's fit he's top class and one of the best defenders in England, easily

Spurs wont let him.

So are you saying you have to play more games to be a better player?

When? 5 games a season it seems these days. Sure, who needs to play games let's just let rep get you by these days.

I'm saying it's hard to be called such a valuable player when you only get by 5 league games a year. Dodgy knees ftw.

What's this game based on? Ability, and when he's fit he's one of the best defenders in the league he played enough games in the previous season before last to show that he isn't "finished"

If you can't play the games no point having the ability. Simples. It's not purely based on ability btw.

Again, he was fit for 6 league games this season. Huge valuable contribution Ledley.

You know how knee injuries work so i'm guessing? Oh wait, you haven't a clue. they get worse over time and it's only going to get worse for King.

So Smalling started 10 games this season eh? 5 games difference, Phil Jones would have been a better pick seeing as he played more games.

Everybody is clueless compared to you Dave

How many other competition games has Smalling played aswell? Smalling was facing competition from two of the best centre backs in the world aswell.

Finally you're starting to get it.

He played 33 mate

IIRC this is Premiership only so anything else doesn't count, you should have chosen someone else that has played more games.

Games started.

Anyways bed for me, long day tommorow.

So when it suits other competitions count? Now that it doesn't they no longer do? Make up your mind man.

I chose a Premier League winner. Smalling this season>King.

Unlike Ledley King who only does 5 hours days these days

Pfft. Run away like Canto.

23 games started, 33 games played.

King - 9 games played in total, unsure about starts/subs.