was thinkin the same thing, always do wen i c these 'versus' debates they usually end up in player slanging!And why should we be taking sides with players wearing the same red shirt we all should adore?
but at same time give a good debate. personally its rooney for me. impact player, always puts in 100%, lifts the crowd and is energy and drive is amazing. when rooney doesnt play its clear to c the difference in our game most of the time.
but thats not to say i dont rate the berb. was a bit taken aback at 1st (mainly due to price tag but thts not the players fault) he has has improved as the season has gone on. personally i think he will get better as season continues