[CROoney]

both do but rooney has a bigger effect. when he gets the ball u feel it in the crowd he will make good use of the ball.
Cro, ur a good man for gettin the debates going, keep it up:thumbsup:

no i'm not a good man - i hate debating - i hate berabtov that's why i opened this thread


i hate ferdinand for thinking that vida's better


now let's see who else do i hate


well back last season there were many criticising his first touch, passing, calling him unfit and his wastefullness in front of goal was a special mention so...it all relative and timing of the subject has to be right


if you remember

 

[hatedastarfish]

no i'm not a good man - i hate debating - i hate berabtov that's why i opened this thread


i hate ferdinand for thinking that vida's better


now let's see who else do i hate


well back last season there were many criticising his first touch, passing, calling him unfit and his wastefullness in front of goal was a special mention so...it all relative and timing of the subject has to be right


if you remember

wasnt a member last season so cant comment on tht

 

[MsUnited]

according to goals they assisited to eachother they're more compatible than rooney and berbatov

it seems saf did a bloody nonsense in milan then

and back when he took off rooney against arsenal i think

Are you talking about this only season where Berbatov was present ? Or the overall statistics of Tevez along with Roo eh?
And anyone can assist a goal anyways, most of them are assisted by midfielders. Its their both overall goals which really counts in this case.

 

[papu1918]

wow - funny how you all avoid taking sides _

either rooney or berba - c'mon lads

Better take a rest,small rest mate.
I am not care who is better. I am enjoed to see both of them together .

 

[RN10]

Rooney, i'd pick rooney over any player in the world except maybe eto'o

 

[RN10]

no i'm not a good man - i hate debating - i hate berabtov that's why i opened this thread

Why what's he ever done to you?

 

[MsUnited]

Why what's he ever done to you?

He stole his girl

I`m joking CROo

 

[hatedastarfish]

Why what's he ever done to you?

i thinks hes bein sarcastic its just wat everyone elses perception of his opinion of the berb is

 

[MsUnited]

i thinks hes bein sarcastic its just wat everyone elses perception of his opinion of the berb is

i don`t think "hate" is the suitable word for someone like Berbatov tho .. Dislike more of

 

[hatedastarfish]

i don`t think "hate" is the suitable word for someone like Berbatov tho .. Dislike more of

that works i think criticizing a player after just over half a season at the club is a bit harsh tho. im happy as a team were doin so well!

 

[MsUnited]

that works i think criticizing a player after just over half a season at the club is a bit harsh tho. im happy as a team were doin so well!

I agree of course, can`t see why someone should dislike Berbatov let alone hating him ! He took his time to settle, fair enough, he found his feet now and is producing better performances altho he can still have shaky games at times. All this is completely normal for me tho, all players pass from such phases. Can`t see what`s all the fuss for. Maybe its because its Berbatov ? I don`t know

 

[hatedastarfish]

I agree of course, can`t see why someone should dislike Berbatov let alone hating him ! He took his time to settle, fair enough, he found his feet now and is producing better performances altho he can still have shaky games at times. All this is completely normal for me tho, all players pass from such phases. Can`t see what`s all the fuss for. Maybe its because its Berbatov ? I don`t know

good points at 1st he wasnt scoring too many in the league, but since december hes been doin well. as i said befor (could be another thread) his best has yet to come.

as for the fuss, its prob the 30m fee, but thats not his fault. he will pay it back in goals and trophies and memorable moments in the coming seasons:first:

plus hes very stylish!

 

[MsUnited]

good points at 1st he wasnt scoring too many in the league, but since december hes been doin well. as i said befor (could be another thread) his best has yet to come.

as for the fuss, its prob the 30m fee, but thats not his fault. he will pay it back in goals and trophies and memorable moments in the coming seasons:first:

plus hes very stylish!

I`ve always disagreed to include fees when discussing players. It was not going to make any difference if we paid 10mill for him .. The expectations were not going to decrease neither were they going to increase if we paid more. When we signed him we knew what Berbatov was capable of, all we wanted was to see him doing his upmost, end of.

 

[CROoney]

I`ve always disagreed to include fees when discussing players. It was not going to make any difference if we paid 10mill for him .. The expectations were not going to decrease neither were they going to increase if we paid more. When we signed him we knew what Berbatov was capable of, all we wanted was to see him doing his upmost, end of.

really ?


picture this - we bought nani for what 17 million - what do you expect of him


we bought manucho for peanuts -what do you expect from him .- why isn't anyone questioning him

 

[hatedastarfish]

I`ve always disagreed to include fees when discussing players. It was not going to make any difference if we paid 10mill for him .. The expectations were not going to decrease neither were they going to increase if we paid more. When we signed him we knew what Berbatov was capable of, all we wanted was to see him doing his upmost, end of.

exactly but some people dont get it that when a club like united come lookin for a player, the price rises and the fee is not down to the player.

point i was makin by mentioning the fee is tht is usually the reason people are sometimes sceptical of berbs ability (crazy how anyone could doubt his ability i know!)

 

[Keano!]

really ?


picture this - we bought nani for what 17 million - what do you expect of him


we bought manucho for peanuts -what do you expect from him .- why isn't anyone questioning him

we dunno how much Nani was.

All we know is it was 30M for Anderson adn Nani...I believe that Anderson was 29M joke


But fees aren't set by the players anyways...

 

[MsUnited]

really ?


picture this - we bought nani for what 17 million - what do you expect of him


we bought manucho for peanuts -what do you expect from him .- why isn't anyone questioning him

Well oh well, questioning Manucho on a 1 performance basis ? Now i don`t think that`s the best name to choose to prove your argument my mate

Wasn`t expecting anything from Nani when we bought him because i wasn`t sure what his strengths and weaknesses are, now that i know i am waiting for him to improve his weaknesses and keep his pluses on going and if he`ll be able to do that then he will be worth every penny.. :happy

 

[CROoney]

Well oh well, questioning Manucho on a 1 performance basis ? Now i don`t think that`s the best name to choose to prove your argument my mate

Wasn`t expecting anything from Nani when we bought him because i wasn`t sure what his strengths and weaknesses are, now that i know i am waiting for him to improve his weaknesses and keep his pluses on going and if he`ll be able to do that then he will be worth every penny.. :happy

but don't you think that if he was that good he'd be given more chances


and if he was that good probably would have been paid more -


why everyone thinks veron was a flop ?


he actually did some good things but not good enough for 30 million


but pretty solid for what we got back for him ( 20)

 

[MsUnited]

but don't you think that if he was that good he'd be given more chances


and if he was that good probably would have been paid more -


why everyone thinks veron was a flop ?


he actually did some good things but not good enough for 30 million


but pretty solid for what we got back for him ( 20)

Are you talking about Nani or Manucho?

Well if your argument here is about Nani .. in the same argument you can say that if he was as bad as some people say he is, he has already been shown the back door.
And Manucho .. He is on loan to gain more experience because with the strikers available this season he was not going to maintain any first team experience.

 

[Guest]

Try to stay on topic guys