Manchester United Talk banner

1 - 9 of 9 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,457 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
All this talk of Rio's new contract, Negotiations started & fingers crossed, has made me think about who has the Best Defensive pairing in the league.

MANCHESTER UNITED: Immediately I had to say Man U and yes I'm biased but 15 clean sheets don't lie. Perhaps a slight weakness in the air but it doesn't show up often. More concerning is United inability to play rough and tumble i.e. Bolton. Of course Chelsea are equal on 15 clean sheets but then again Man U don't have the luxury of 5 CENTER BACKS. Perhaps in years gone by Terry/Gallas could have laid claim but frankly I believe you'd look long and hard to find a pair of more arrogant, insufferable tantrum throwing louts than those two.:D

CHELSEA: So With Terry in and out and Carvalho struggling for form I think we can discount Chelsea with Alex looking like a top class striker but shaky at best as a center
back, Ben Haim isn't top four material & Ivanovic is MIA, such a shame about that.

ARSENAL: I've said my piece about Gallas & as for Toure he's very good but I honestly just don't know whether I'd call him class. Senderos has been impressing me as he deputizes though so who knows. Arsenal aren't even in the top 5 for clean sheets so they're out.

LIVERPOOL: Carraghers had an up and down year but I put that down to missing Agger terribly. Poor love sick puppy.:p Hyypiä's been descent but that's it and Skrtel has been under terrible pressure in his first premier league season so I won't judge. Lack of a decent partner see's L'pool drop out.

EVERTON: Out side the top four it's been a great season for defenders everywhere. I actually believe you'll find a few center pairings that embarrass the multi million pound defenders who strut around Stamford Bridge and the Emirates like **** of the walk. Lescott, Yobo & Jagielka have all been playing out of their skins & fourth place is the least they deserve. All credit to the genius that is David Moyes.

ASTON VILLA: It's been the rise and rise of Martin Laursen. If anybody could give Lescott a run for his money in the goal scoring defender stakes it's this man. That said Villa definitely deserve an honorable mention for their defensive pairing. If I could work out who it belongs to. Melberg/Laursen would get a top 3 finish easy. The problem inherent is that Melberg is playing right back and about to jump ship and join The Old Lady. So that leave Laursen and Bouma? Knight? Davies? Well whoever they are they're doing a bang up job at any rate.

MAN CITY: Arrrghh! I know! Yet Richards/Dunne have been immense and even with the knee injury keeping Richards out presently I still feel city will cope as long as their captain Dunne remains standing for me he's been the most impressive city player alongside Petrov. Steady as a rock and happy to let Richards soak up the limelight. Very Impressive.

TOTTENHAM: I'm sorry? What? Yeah I know what you're thinking but if King can get a run of games, Bale can get fit and Dawson can start putting pressure on the two of them as ridiculous as it sounds next year Tottenham could have one of the best defenses next year. Including top four teams. Hutton, Woodgate, King, Bale with Dawson waiting in the wings. Crazy isn't it. Ramos, that loony Spaniard. Didn't anyone give him the memo? That building a top team is meant to take years. The memo must have been written in English.

So THE VERDICT: I won't beat around the Bush.

CHELSEA: OUT.

ARSENAL: OUT.

LIVERPOOL: OUT but unfortunate.

ASTON VILLA: RELUCTANTLY OUT. If it was Melberg/Laursen maybe but with
no clue as to who actually is their partnership plus the fact that they can leak
goals at times I can't give it.

MAN CITY: 4th. No not out of spite. As good as Richards/Dunne are, Richards has some growing up to do. City aren't leading cleans sheets mainly due to their away form. Also the rest of the team need to chip in. Attack together, defend together. One feels the missing puzzle piece will click eventually.

EVERTON: 3rd. I know with the current league position and the fact they are 3rd on the clean sheets list behind only Chelsea and Man U this seems like a cop out. Here me out . They are merely third because through no fault of their own Everton's center halves are great but the top two teams center halves are awesome.

MANCHESTER UNITED: 2nd. Okay I'm aware people are fainting now. Some are screaming others trying to track me down to administer a firm smack to the head. Well guess what I believe that Ferdinand/Vidic are the best defensive pairing in the league. So if they're the best why are they second? Good question. To answer that I guess we have to look at number one.

TOTTENHAM: 1st. It's official folks. I've gone Banana's! Goodness only knows how many goals conceded earlier on. Key words, EARLIER ON. So what captivated me so much as to bump the best defensive duo in the league to 2nd place. Well for too long we've seen top four domination in the league and ultimately it came down to defense. Finally I've seen the light. A team outside the top four with a defense equal to any I've seen this year and for several years. How long ago was Hutton a supposed Man U target. How did Ramos pull that off? Money? Sex? Sorcery?Who knows. He already had King so the foundation was laid. He knew Dawson needed a kick up the bum and what better way than to create competition for his place? Woodgate, though? I can't even begin to fathom how Ramos saw the potential there. To say that came out of the blue would be understatement of the year. Bale. Already there true and when he comes back Tottenham will have a wall that's remarkable for so many reason but to put it succinctly. Money. £15 million is a lot of money but to put together a defense that a big four team would have paid twice as much for. Priceless. Reason two. Speed. This defense was put together in the time it would take Ferguson to begin the mind games that are the precursor to haggling/destabilizing the enemy. I.e. Lyon, Benzema. Reason number 3. Desire. For a team to beat the likes of Chelsea you have to keep out the combined talents of Drogba, Kalou, Shevchenko, Pizzaro & last but not least Anelka. Plus Lamps, Ballack, Essien and Alex, Joe Cole, Malouda. Get my point? That's takes real team spirit and desire. Final reason 4. In an age of crisis for English football to have three center halves all of which are top quality defenders is a spectacular feat on it's own. To have three top center halves all of whom are ENGLISH is miraculous on an almost holy scale. Ladies, Gentlemen, I am awed and I am inspired.
Well done Tottenham. Well Done Ramos.:)
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
9,926 Posts
Great post btw.

I think our weakness is the 'aul set-pieces. We do conced silly
goals sometimes, but without a shadow of a doubt, we do
have the best pairing. On their day Vidic and Ferdinand really
excell. I don't rate the Terry and Carvalho one as much as I
used to but they're still good. Arsenal, ehh.......if Gallas is in
top form and Senderos doesn't have a shocker, then they can
be ok too. Liverpool have an OAP, and who knows who their
next one will be in defence, so lets not go there. Outside of
us, the big four, Spurs really do have the pairing to admire. I
really lik Dawson as a player and people have often critised
me for doing so, but, despite the odd lapse, he's a quality
player. With Ledley King coming back too, they are really
going to be tough to break down. (Glad we're finished with
them this season!) To be honest, they actually have a good
defence overall.

So yea, I'd agree that Tottenham have a great defence, but
on our day.....nothing gets by. And then they also have to
put it past VDS!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,544 Posts
No matter juz/ how much class Rio possessed & how much steel Vida brings to the team, there has been some awkward moments of lapses in concentration. The good thing is, it doesn't happen frequently. If Spuds can keep both Ledley King & Jonathan Woodgate fit and raring to go, they gotta' be one of the main contenders for the best centre-back pairing in the Premiership! ;)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,814 Posts
Tottenham???????

as good as they look on paper we havent really seen the King Woodgate pairing in action, they have decent overpriced young full backs with bags of potential but at the end of the day their two centre halves are second rate english players... with injury problems!

There's v few defencive partnerships better than United and Chelsea's they're both flawless in all areas!!

And nicely put together post dude!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
25,467 Posts
Great effort with your post by the way :)

I think Rio/Vida are streets ahead of anyone else.
Id go as far to say they are the best pairing in Europe.
You voted for Spurs and I see the reasoning but they
have only played a game or 2 together. There is no doubting
the quality of King/Woody but they will always struggle with
injuries.
I think Villa will have a great pairing. Mellberg plays rb btw
so Its Davies/laursen in the middle. They will go on to great
things once they play week in week out.

Chelsea and Arse have quality also. They wouldnt be too far behind.
Terry/Carvalho havent played together at all this season (just a few games)

So Id go:
1.United
2.Chelsea(when fit)
3.Arse
4.Spurs(when fit)
5.City
6.Villa
but when they are fit they are both world class players as are
Gallas/Toure...... On their day they are as good as anyone though
they have been exposed on occasion this season.
I like Dunne/Richards combo. i think Dunne is one of the best in the Prem.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,544 Posts
Woody May Not Get Blues

http://www.football365.com/story/0,17033,8652_3210457,00.html

Tottenham centre-back Jonathan Woodgate has emerged as a doubt for the Premier League clash at Birmingham on Saturday after playing through the pain of a sprained ankle during the Carling Cup final.

The 28-year-old picked up the injury in the first half of the win over Chelsea but did not tell Spurs medical staff until after the final whistle following his Wembley winner.

Woodgate's career has included a series of injury disappointments but the current problem for the January signing from Middlesbrough is not considered serious.

Head coach Juande Ramos said before the final: "The decision to buy him came after 15-18 months playing regularly, with his injury history over with. If he goes on the same lines he will be indispensable."

Fellow centre-half Ledley King is unlikely to play at St Andrews either after featuring last weekend, with the Spurs skipper still being brought back gradually from knee surgery.

Ramos is also having to take into consideration the UEFA Cup clash against PSV Eindhoven the following Thursday.

The good news for the Spaniard is defenders Michael Dawson and Gilberto are dging closer to full training following respective hamstring and calf injuries.

But left-backs Benoit Assou-Ekotto (knee) and Gareth Bale (foot) have been ruled out for the season.

Meanwhile, Pascal Chimbonda apologised to his Spurs team-mates on the bus after the Wembley victory for storming straight down the tunnel when he was substituted.

Full-back Alan Hutton said: "Even on the bus back he was saying sorry for that, but we were saying it's not a problem. It's fine. It's understandable."


Injured again....!!! :eek: :D :p
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
248 Posts
I think Vidic-Rio is the best pairing by far. United have possibly the best defence in the prem if we get a decent right back. Tottenham have a good defence too :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,457 Posts
Discussion Starter #8
"With Woodgate out injured, Ramos looks likely to rest Skipper Ledley King with one eye on the UEFA cup clash with PSV"

No King. No Woodgate. Makes Tottenham an easy target. Thumped 4 -1 by Birmingham. I don't think anyone saw that scoreline coming. Did they? Well I honestly couldn't have asked for a better plight to highlight my point. Just how important those two are to Tottenham. It's more than quality. It's the comfort and reassurance that when they're there Spurs don't have to worry about conceding four to the likes of Birmingham. :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,544 Posts
Well, I juz' disagree to ur thinking that the Jonathan Woodgate-Ledley King centre-back pairing's the best in the world. Imagine a centre-back pairing of the two best centre-backs ever, Sir Bobby Moore & Franz Beckenbauer, were injured for 3/4 of the whole season, meaning that they play only approximately 15 games per season? Will they hve that much influence on the team defense??
 
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
Top