[marty davidson]

With the transfer window just closed which sigining do you think will be the best and why ?

 

[piazza]

Probably Given, you always know you're going to get solid performances out of him.

 

[Jay007]

There wasn't many to get excited about tbh.

Off the top of my head, I'll say Keane to Spurs. He could be a masterstroke and get them to safety.

 

[Sownak27]

Given

And Jo for Everton if he can fire

 

[RedForceRising]

As far as Man Utd are concerened the best transfer was Robbie Keane back to Spurs!

 

[Mufc-Taff]

i think ...

i read that is official

Arshavin to Arsenal

 

[Fiat Cunto]

given is my choice as i think hes one of the best if not the best and most consistent keeper in the prem it says a lot about him that he can concede 5 goals against liverpoo and still come out with credit and plaudits! just upset he has to go from suuch a mediocre club to another

 

[VaVa]

Seamus Given to City. City are second only to Chelsea on goals scored, with Given on goal they can climb up the table. Quality

 

[Jazz 16]

Without a doubt Shay Given. Arseshaving to arse would be 2nd.

 

[red dave]

I almost cried when I read someone had put Jo if he get firing lol!!!!!!!!!!!

On a serious note I think either Bellamy or Defoe will be the better signings of the window.

 

[Jazz 16]

I almost cried when I read someone had put Jo if he get firing lol!!!!!!!!!!!

On a serious note I think either Bellamy or Defoe will be the better signings of the window.

Give Jo a chance. Everton needed a striker and he clearly wasnt going to play at City.
I happen to think he will do alright at Everton.
Bellamy is a debatable one. With all their money they went out and got him
They could have done better imo, though he is still a good player.

and Defoe is crocked, possibly for a few months, so that hasnt worked out well.
Keane will be a better signing than Defoe in the long run.

I think Arshavin could be class.

 

[thekeanefella]

shay given

He is world class and will prove to be a very astute signing by mark hughes.

 

[martinutd]

Shay given. Great goalkeeper at the wrong club

 

[PeeJay]

Momo Diarra, quite expensive but an excellent player.

Oh and I remember a lot of people saying "sell Ronaldo,
buy Quaresma and Huntelaar" and I was just asking myself
what kind of football fans we attract.

Well, Quaresma's been mediocre in Italy, so good thing he
went to Chelsea and Huntelaar isn't looking exceptional.

Just goes to show that just because you perform in Portugal,
Holland or Croatia doesn't mean you'll perform in the Big Leagues.

Oh and Liverpool must be laughing all the way to the bank.

 

[RtiD]

Well Given good signing for city.
I think Jo could be an excellent signing for Everton if he gets regular games and gets to adjust to the premier league he will get them goals.

 

[Check the Milkman]

Given. What an f'in keeper. Best in the league IMO.

 

[Because I'm DC]

Momo Diarra, quite expensive but an excellent player.

Oh and I remember a lot of people saying "sell Ronaldo,
buy Quaresma and Huntelaar" and I was just asking myself
what kind of football fans we attract.

Well, Quaresma's been mediocre in Italy, so good thing he
went to Chelsea and Huntelaar isn't looking exceptional.

Just goes to show that just because you perform in Portugal,
Holland or Croatia doesn't mean you'll perform in the Big Leagues.

Oh and Liverpool must be laughing all the way to the bank.

What do you mean? Momo Diarra? You mean Lassana Diarra? He was twenty million, and completely unproven. I thought that was a terrible signing personally.

 

[abojodeh]

Given Arshavin and Defoe

 

[PeeJay]

Yeah, Lassana Diarra.

He was never given a chance at Arsenal or Chelsea but
he's been excellent for Portsmouth and Real Madrid.

Arshavin is incredibly overrated and I doubt he'll excel.

As for Jo, he looked alright for CSKA.

 

[marty davidson]

Defoe for me