[RichardsReds]

http://www.d1g.com/video/show/1790408

Anyone have any opinions they'd like to share?

 

[Arrogant Frog Eater]

Eh he missed Nani's knee...

This is not shocking me, this is football not ballet dancing

 

[eoininho]

pretty bad and dangerous tackle, studs up... could have done serious damage if he'd connected!

iv seen reds given for this type of tackle!

if he had gotten a red, he wouldn be in the situation hes in now!!!

 

[unitedred]

Karma is a bitch.

 

[Justice]

Karma is fair and just.

Your post needed fixing.

 

[unitedred]

Hehe

 

[Jazz 16]

Not quite sure I get the point of this thread.....
Are you in some way suggesting that Eduardo got his
just rewards? We have a thread on Eduardo's horrific
injury. i dont think we need this one to start slating
the poor lad. He is out for 9 months so leave him be.

 

[unitedred]

Yep, might aswell merge it with that thread.

Don't think anybodys slating him per se, well not me anyway but just referring to him putting in an extremely dangerous tackle himself only a week before he got done by one. Some believe in Karma....

 

[Jazz 16]

Yep, might aswell merge it with that thread.

Don't think anybodys slating him per se, well not me anyway but just referring to him putting in an extremely dangerous tackle himself only a week before he got done by one. Some believe in Karma....

well no point merging them as its sort of a different topic....
I just think this thread might get unwarranted messages.
Maybe Eduardo's tackle was nasty (well it was)
but you cant kick a dog when he's down.

 

[man.utd.singh]

Eduado should be banned 4 life.

Hmm seems like if it was us, the sore loser would of been goin crazy

 

[CROoney]

wow ! life's a bitch aint it ? he should ahve been banned for 1-3 matches for that tackle imo. If he had been banned he wouldn't have played a match in which he was brutally injured ! I say - bring the bans !

 

[alto10]

Bet he wishes he had been sent off now, Karma is just and fair

 

[babysenorita]

Its football people...these kind of tackle tend to happen with or without purpose and in this case, Nani is lucky enough to get off it but Eduardo didnt sadly...call karma as you want but its just tragic and no one deserved such injury.

 

[RichardsReds]

I was tempting people to answer where can you draw the line on what is and isn't a bad tackle. Its easy to say it is once the damamge is done. IMO that tackle on Nani is very bad as well. If we want to avoid injurys like the Edwardo one these type of tackles need to be punished.

People keep saying it but i see no action. Will we have to see more horrific injurys before players stop diving into stupid challenges?

 

[Jazz 16]

Will we have to see more horrific injurys before players stop diving into stupid challenges?

I think we will always see horrific injuries, whether the players dive in or not.
Its a contact sport with lots of twisting and turning and accidents do happen.
Sure the bad ones need to be punished but the game will never be free from
horrific injuries or tackles. Its just part of the game.

 

[fazman]

Yeh thats arsenal all over they never see there bad tackles im sorry it happened to him but if its gonna happen to any teams then its got to be arsenal , liverpool or chelsea

 

[Natalie]

and then wenger says that everyone kicks arsenal

 

[Red Devil]

wow ! life's a bitch aint it ? he should ahve been banned for 1-3 matches for that tackle imo. If he had been banned he wouldn't have played a match in which he was brutally injured ! I say - bring the bans !

he WAS - a red card is a ban. That is sufficient punishment for a mistimed tackle, and thats all it was.

 

[babysenorita]

I think we will always see horrific injuries, whether the players dive in or not.
Its a contact sport with lots of twisting and turning and accidents do happen.
Sure the bad ones need to be punished but the game will never be free from
horrific injuries or tackles. Its just part of the game.

Remember Alan Smith? He was not even tackled, all it takes is a wrong landing or a wrong footing and such were the injuries he suffered.

 

[conor myles]

Eduardo you dirtbag same old arsenal always cheating