you're missing the point...it's not about who's more succesfull, it's about tactics...it's like saying , fat ronaldo was a great striker but he isn't excactly great with playing his head..and then you all go "What ???? He's amoung the greatest that ever lived !!!! "...so ? he was not as good with his head as inzaghi or bierhoff were..it's one aspect of a play required to succeed..whats better... a bourbon, or a custard cream?
just like tactics is only one apsect of a managerial bussines...you can be the greatest tactitian in the world with crappy players and you won't achieve anything