Manchester United Talk banner

Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 40 Posts
S

·
Guest
Joined
·
0 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Seeing as the other thread is locked, quite sensibly to stop it getting clogged up with questions/chat etc, i thought i would put this here for peoples thoughts/questions etc.

I've been on other forums where they have the same sort of thing and having a secret vote is not the best way to do it in my opinion.
It leaves the vote collectors open to accusations of cheating/vote rigging etc etc.
Very easy for them to do and no-one would be any the wiser.

Much better to have an open vote where everyone can see the votes and impossible to alter/fix the results.

Also if a vote collectors inbox is full people cannot then vote unless the person clears PMs.

.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,708 Posts
Now,that's the spirit......screw you mods:eek:

I don't trust them neither.........especially to Ajant..........and Jazzy boy.........and Carly...........and...did I said Jazz:D


no seriuosly,I'm for open votes too;)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
25,467 Posts
You have a point Sal.....
Only Skele and Bert have left votes for me. Not sure why the interest isnt there yet but this thread could help.
Carly and Aj have been working hard behind the scenes to set this up, so not sure if changing now would be feasable or not. Ill have to check it with them.

I dont see any problem with people posting their views on people here, regarding the Awards. It could add interest and make sure we dont rig it (as if we would tut tut)

Either way, people should get voting soon.

http://www.manutdtalk.com/forums/announcements/4988-member-awards-2007-a.html
 
S

·
Guest
Joined
·
0 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
Jazz 16 said:
You have a point Sal.....
Only Skele and Bert have left votes for me. Not sure why the interest isnt there yet but this thread could help.
Carly and Aj have been working hard behind the scenes to set this up, so not sure if changing now would be feasable or not. Ill have to check it with them.

I dont see any problem with people posting their views on people here, regarding the Awards. It could add interest and make sure we dont rig it (as if we would tut tut)

Either way, people should get voting soon.

http://www.manutdtalk.com/forums/announcements/4988-member-awards-2007-a.html
I think the interest might not be there for the same reason as me.
I havn't voted because i can't be bothered copying/pasting the first lot in a PM with two names for each, then going back to the thread, doing the same another two times and sending PMs to different collectors. Bit too much messing around for me, sorry.

Would be easier to have 1 - 9 down the page and one vote for each cattagory.

.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,014 Posts
Myself and red devil as debator of the year ( dolphins and the japanese);)
Charles and salford for best united knowledge
Most like to meet sols and jazz (sorry k4 )
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
4,956 Posts
OK here is the categories.....

Copy paste this and choose 2 (TWO) for each section.....

Then we hold the polls for winners.......

-best member

-best debater

-best member of staff

-funniest member

-best newcomer(from past 6 months)

-best thread

-funniest post

-best manchester united football knowledge

-diehard fan of the year



I have 3 sets of results here already and soon I post these.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,572 Posts
Yes, I knew haviung 3 people woulds tuff people around, I'm MORE than happy to get everyone to send their NOMINATIONS not votes to me, then we set up POLLS for votes, and that's OPEN to the public. OPEN. Not closed behind the scenes voting as it's been called...

I don't know why we're making the effort to be honest...

...so open nominate here, then we'll set up polls so you can vote? or shall we stop trying to attract more interest and forget about trying to recognise people for their good work for a bit of fun? thought you spammers liked that?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,270 Posts
Ajant said:
Yes, I knew haviung 3 people woulds tuff people around, I'm MORE than happy to get everyone to send their NOMINATIONS not votes to me, then we set up POLLS for votes, and that's OPEN to the public. OPEN. Not closed behind the scenes voting as it's been called...

I don't know why we're making the effort to be honest...

I don't know either!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,236 Posts
rydersonthestorm said:
Myself and red devil as debator of the year ( dolphins and the japanese);)
Charles and salford for best united knowledge
Most like to meet sols and jazz (sorry k4 )
Keano's fan and CROoney are also good debators..............

Reddwarf has superb knowledge also.........

And don't worry ryder, I've already met/been intimate with you, even if you don't know it yet.....;)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
25,467 Posts
Ah dont be so downbeat about it......
Its just a bit of fun and its nice for a few to be recognised.......
It would be great if you could take the time to vote.
Just fill whatever sections you want to.

And no negative remarks please.......If you dont want to vote thats your choice, just dont spoil it for the rest.

there may also be 1/2 vcash in it for whoever votes ;-) no promises though...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,895 Posts
Personally, I think it is a good idea. Good for morale and all that fun stuff. I just think the delivery might have confused a few people.

Anyway, my nominations:

-best member - Carly, Sal Red

-best debater - Sal Red, RD

-best member of staff - <already a poll on this>

-funniest member - K4T, STD

-best newcomer(from past 6 months) - Um.. wait, how long have I been here? I think Dec = 6 months for me :D

-best thread - Doughnut thief faces 30 year sentence or Say Anything

-funniest post - <insert anything from K4T here>

-best manchester united football knowledge - Sal Red, Jazz

-diehard fan of the year - Sal Red, Carly

... just can't beat Grandpa ;)
 
S

·
Guest
Joined
·
0 Posts
Discussion Starter #16
-best member ...Everyone...in thier own different way

-best debater....Ryders and CRooney

-best newcomer..Zuco and Skele

-funniest member...STL (drunk) K4t (being gay).

-best thread...Munich thread, Manchester United History thread.

-funniest post....too many have made me laugh to pick two.

-best manchester united football knowledge (3 nominations ). Charles, Stephen, Ryders

-diehard fan of the year,.. Charles(50 yrs!! no contest ) and Stephen
.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
4,956 Posts
I HAD THESE RESULTS SENT TO ME.....

SO GUYS YOU NEED TO FILL THE REST IN TO COMPLETE YOUR VOTES.....

George Voted:

-best member CARLY......JAZZ

-best debater CROONEY.......RYDER

-best newcomer SOLSK......K4T

-funniest member

-best thread

-funniest post

-best manchester united football knowledge

-diehard fan of the year




Skele Voted:

-best member SAL......K4T

-best debater RYDER......SAL

-best newcomer SOLSK......AG

-funniest member

-best thread

-funniest post

-best manchester united football knowledge

-diehard fan of the year




K4T VOTED:

-best member CARLY......AG

-best debater KEANOS FAN......CROONEY

-best newcomer AG......AMUCHAN

-funniest member

-best thread

-funniest post

-best manchester united football knowledge

-diehard fan of the year
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,236 Posts
carlyluvsunited said:
I HAD THESE RESULTS SENT TO ME.....

SO GUYS YOU NEED TO FILL THE REST IN TO COMPLETE YOUR VOTES.....


K4T VOTED:

-best member CARLY......AG

-best debater KEANOS FAN......CROONEY

-best newcomer AG......AMUCHAN

-funniest member CARLY.......ANDYCOLE9

-best thread "who'd you most like to meet"........."member hot seat thread"

-funniest post
carlyluvsunited said:
Who is Rupert and Paddngton ?

Are they better than Adriano ?

Anderson's God said:
I am slow beginning to understand you K4T but my aim has far from been achieved, I am trying to get an idea of what goes on inside that head of yours!
Build up a strong character profile .......... lol

-best manchester united football knowledge REDDWARF..........SALFORD RED

-diehard fan of the year JAZZ 16.........SKELE



This voting system should have been simple, yet you guys still manage to confuse everyone and end up with pm's, threads.....and posts........:rolleyes:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,861 Posts
-best member Jazz_16, Carly

-best debater Ryder, Keano's Fan

-best member of staff *i voted on a poll*

-funniest member AndyCole9

-best newcomer(from past 6 months) Ryder

-best thread the history and munich threads

-funniest post the one by carly about Adriano and paddington

-best manchester united football knowledge SALFORDRED, Red Devil

-diehard fan of the year reddwarf, Stephen


--------------------------

ill keep on editing this to add more nominations
 
1 - 20 of 40 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top