Jazz-Man ..this is a good topic!
I quickly glanced over the lists of my fellow posters and see mostly the same names and I tend to agree. What I do not agree with is Ronaldo being number 1.
The term consistent itself means that if you look at a players performance in EVERY game he played, he has delivered a same level of performance.
So the title must go to ......................Tomasz Kuszczak! For being conistently shaky in goal!
Just kidding, of course. I know you mean consistently good performances and that title must go to. PATRICE EVRA.
Ronaldo has been getting all the headlines, but he has a very bad days too when he was maybe 6 out o 10 performance wise.
The same cannot be said of Patrice Evra.
He's never dropped below 7 the entire season. Even when Arron Lennon was giving him a torrid time against Spurs away, he still delivered a good performance. He gets my vote for the most consistent player of the season.
1. Patrice Evra
2. Rio Ferdinand
3. Nemanja Vidic
4. Ronaldo
5. Anderson