Joined
·
15,336 Posts
This thread will probably be closed, and some mods will go on about how there are far too many threads about yesterday but I really need to get this off my chest.
Its really bugging me how, after a terrible performance yesterday, whenever anyone expresses their opinion about what went wrong etc, they are crucified for it.
Now, no words can describe the job that Sir Alex has done at Man Utd, and no words can describe how grateful we are and how much we love him. But that doesn't make him immune to criticism.
Yes, some of it goes far too far. Things like "Sir Alex is entirely too blame for yesterdays defeat" and "Sir Alex was completely wrong" are too far. Far too far in fact, and I can understand why people get annoyed by that and I too get annoyed for ridiculous statements like that.
Yes, it wasn't all his fault yesterday. But he did make mistakes as well, and we are as entitled to discuss them as much as VDS's mistake or Giggs' mistake.
However, some people who have posted constructive criticism have been crucified. Again, he isn't immune to criticism.
Some people claim he shouldn't get criticism because he doesn't step out onto the pitch and the performance is not his fault. These same people, however, continually praise him when things go right. But he doesn't go onto the pitch then either, does he?
If Sir Alex gets the praise for when things go right, then I see no reason why he shouldn't get some of the blame when things go wrong.
Its really bugging me how, after a terrible performance yesterday, whenever anyone expresses their opinion about what went wrong etc, they are crucified for it.
Now, no words can describe the job that Sir Alex has done at Man Utd, and no words can describe how grateful we are and how much we love him. But that doesn't make him immune to criticism.
Yes, some of it goes far too far. Things like "Sir Alex is entirely too blame for yesterdays defeat" and "Sir Alex was completely wrong" are too far. Far too far in fact, and I can understand why people get annoyed by that and I too get annoyed for ridiculous statements like that.
Yes, it wasn't all his fault yesterday. But he did make mistakes as well, and we are as entitled to discuss them as much as VDS's mistake or Giggs' mistake.
However, some people who have posted constructive criticism have been crucified. Again, he isn't immune to criticism.
Some people claim he shouldn't get criticism because he doesn't step out onto the pitch and the performance is not his fault. These same people, however, continually praise him when things go right. But he doesn't go onto the pitch then either, does he?
If Sir Alex gets the praise for when things go right, then I see no reason why he shouldn't get some of the blame when things go wrong.