Manchester United Talk banner

1 - 5 of 5 Posts

·
Moderator
Joined
·
23,699 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Keane Speaks Of What A Captain Should Be… In Light Of Arsenal Ex-Skipper’s Remarks

Roy Keane was a superb captain, something which is undeniable to even those that hate the man. His ability was never the greatest on the field, but his passion, desire and commitment outweighed anything his team mates and usually opposition had to offer.

“He did not have the ability of someone like Eric Cantona or Ryan Giggs or Paul Scholes but he had this fire in his stomach which gets them there,” said Sir Alex Ferguson last year. “He was not the quickest player but he was always first to the ball. In terms of sheer influence, he was the best player I have ever had.”

We couldn’t have asked for better than Keano, but he left the club under a cloud, only to return months later for his testimonial, saying goodbye to the fans and making his peace with Ferguson.

With great passion and determination, there will usually come a wicked temper, something we have seen in several of our best players. It was that temper which cost Keane his position within our club.

“Just because you are paid £120,000-a-week and play well for 20 minutes against Tottenham, you think you are a superstar,” ranting Keane in the interview that was pulled before airing on MUTV, following the 4-1 defeat at Middlesbrough. “The younger players have been let down by some of the more experienced players. They are just not of characters in the team. It seems to be in this club that you have to play badly to be rewarded. Maybe that is what I should do when I come back. Play badly.”

Keane had let a few home truths be known over the years at United, particularly after the Treble winning season when some players seem to take their foot off the gas. He had always been on his team mates back, enforcing they always strove for perfection. The MUTV interview back in 2005 was no different, accept this time there was a chance of the public getting their hands on it.

“I wasn’t surprised by the result I had been expecting one like this,” he continued. “The players have been asked questions and they are just not coming up with the answers. I am sick of having to say it and they are sick of listening to me. They have let down the club, the manager, and the fans. When they sign the contracts, they think they have made it. They owe it to the manager, the staff and the fans.”

At the time and to this day, I do not think it was Roy Keane’s place to attack the players in the way he did. On the front of Red Issue that week, the picture showed Ferguson and Keane, the manager with a speech bubble saying “You shouldn’t have said those things,” to which Keane responded, “No, you should!” Whilst I see the importance of a captain, they are not in a position to start slating their team mates in public. Keane got ideas above his station, although I understand his position came from the frustration of seeing United fail. His best years were behind him, he knew he didn’t have much time left in him with his knackered hips, but he wanted the best for Manchester United.

He has today responded to questions about Gallas’ decision to slag off his team mates to a tabloid, which have seemingly lead to the captaincy being taken from him. Whilst Keane was looking out for his club, Gallas is only concerned with number one.

“I am trying to defend myself a bit without giving names,” Gallas said. “Otherwise I’m taking it all (the blame). It’s very frustrating,”

We first saw his selfishness at Birmingham, laying in to Gael Clichy after he gave away a penalty, then leaving his team mates to it, marching to the half way line. Had the keeper made a save and the rebound put away the man Gallas should have been marking, maybe the Arsenal fans would have seen their captain’s behaviour as crazy as everyone else.

As the team mates rushed off for news on Eduardo’s injury, captain Gallas remained on the pitch, crying by himself.

Speaking from experience, Keane gave his opinion on the Gallas situation.

“I used to quite a bit,” Keane said when asked if Gallas was wrong to criticise. “But there are ways of doing it.” Obviously implying that speaking to a nationwide rag that will twist and dramatise everything you say isn’t the best way to go.

“You just hope you have a strong dressing room,” Keane continued. “You hope you have a few captains in your dressing room to take care of things. I was lucky in my playing days that we had some strong characters and we used to deal with what ever was going on in the dressing room. If I was missing something, which I very rarely did, then there was another couple of players to spot things. A good dressing room and a good captain can make the manager’s job easier. Everyone has the right to say what they feel every now and again and if it upsets people, so what? People are too easily upset these days.”

http://therepublikofmancunia.com/ke...ould-be-in-light-of-arsenal-skippers-remarks/


In light of Gallas's highly inappropriate revelation and now Keano lending his two cents' worth, perhaps this topic of captaincy may raise some interest.

What factors do you reckon would make a manager appoint one as a captain? Seniority, footballing abilities, leadership, characters, inspiration etc? Before you think it is a straight forward answer, do consider if the non-vocal Gary is a captain by seniority after the departure of Keano and in his absence, Giggs and Rio in that order, obviously another seniority suspect? No? Or would hate-to-lose Rooney ever wear the armband, given his not-too-exemplary discipline? Or must he wait till he is one of the most senior in the sqaud? Know what I mean?

Or what factor(s) do you reckon are the most important then to be a good captain? Consider the different captains for different teams with different characteristics. Then perhaps it is not so clear cut again.

Or is good captaincy inborn or can be learned?
 

·
MUT all-time great
Joined
·
21,962 Posts
There was an interview given by Robbie Earle, on a radio show here in which he talked in explicit detail about how Roy Keane was the greatest footballer AND captain he'd ever played against. He also said he was crazier than Vinnie Jones; but that's for another time.

Anyway, essentially what he said, was that Keane knew exactly what to say or do to motivate certain teammates. He spoke of one instance in which, Scholesy was having an off-day and Keane said something to the effect of "you gotta make those passes, because you're the only one who can!" In that he managed to let Paul Scholes know, that he was upset with him, while simultaneously giving him a pat on the back.

My personal opinion, from reading his book is that his upbringing in Cork and his influence from people such as Stuart Pearce, Brian Clough and most of all Sir Alex Ferguson has a lot to do with his capabilities not only as a footballer but as a captain as well.
 

·
He wipes front to back
Joined
·
27,654 Posts
the captain needs to be an extention of the manager . once they take the field the manager can have little effect . fergie always said of keane that he was his general on the pitch -- roys problem was he thought he needed to be boss off it and there was only ever going to be one winner there . gallas is a disgrace as a captain and should have been stripped of it when he went and sulked in the other half when a pen was awarded against his side . if the pen was saved his job is to clear the rebound yet he was bawling like a bairn so maybe gallas is wengers extention after all !!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,207 Posts
BTW, Rio should get the arm band, because I find it difficult to believe
that the rest of the players can really look up to Ryan and Gazza the
way they used to.

Both are getting on in years and are not the players they once were.

How can they rouse the rest when they are falling short themselves?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,547 Posts
haggler said:
the captain needs to be an extention of the manager . once they take the field the manager can have little effect . fergie always said of keane that he was his general on the pitch -- roys problem was he thought he needed to be boss off it and there was only ever going to be one winner there . gallas is a disgrace as a captain and should have been stripped of it when he went and sulked in the other half when a pen was awarded against his side . if the pen was saved his job is to clear the rebound yet he was bawling like a bairn so maybe gallas is wengers extention after all !!!!
Im not saying its wrong to have a captain who is the eye in the locker room for the manager. But to me thats a bit of the old school. When everything comes from above and you just shut up and do as your told.

A good captain for me should be as much as the extention for the manager but also representing the players infront of the manager, staff and club board. Also, the captain should be the face of the club to the world outside as well but most important is that he can be the link between manager > players > manager.
 
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
Top