Manchester United Talk banner
1 - 19 of 19 Posts

·
Berbatov>Tevez
Joined
·
11,076 Posts
Well Jagielka has had a brillant season and deserves to be up there.
I thought Upson done pretty well too.
But no way should Carragher be up there.
but no way they're better than rio


carrick for example can have a great season but he will never be in the same league as lampard or gerrard


sure sure - they're completely different players and i like the guy but he will never be in their league as jagielka and upson will never be in rio's league imo


btw - ronaldo and messi are different players but yet people can compare them right ?

IMO
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,017 Posts
but no way they're better than rio


carrick for example can have a great season but he will never be in the same league as lampard or gerrard


sure sure - they're completely different players and i like the guy but he will never be in their league as jagielka and upson will never be in rio's league imo


IMO
Ya but this is going on this season alone - therefore I feel Jagielka deserves to be up there.
IMO Jagielka and Lescott have been brillant for Everton all season.

I'm not sure how Upson has got that many votes, but all the same he's had a good season too.

If Carrick had a better season than Lampard or Gerrard - then he would be up there.
But the simple fact is that he hasn't.

Overall yes, Rio is a far better defender than both Upson and Jagielka, obviously - but going on this season alone. Rio hasn't be as good as them, well not Jagielka anyway IMO.
 

·
Berbatov>Tevez
Joined
·
11,076 Posts
Ya but this is going on this season alone - therefore I feel Jagielka deserves to be up there.
IMO Jagielka and Lescott have been brillant for Everton all season.

I'm not sure how Upson has got that many votes, but all the same he's had a good season too.

If Carrick had a better season than Lampard or Gerrard - then he would be up there.
But the simple fact is that he hasn't.

Overall yes, Rio is a far better defender than both Upson and Jagielka, obviously - but going on this season alone. Rio hasn't be as good as them, well not Jagielka anyway IMO.
maybe you're right


haven't actually closely followed them

apart from carragher who's always on the same level - ok but won't save your ass
 
1 - 19 of 19 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top