[Faisal || Red Alert ||]

Hi guys,

I was just wondering if sir Alex Ferguson would let Danny Simpson go on loan when the january transfer window re-opens.
Because there are some intrested clubs such as Sunderland.
I think that guy need to play permanintly in the premier league to get some experience because he really need it.
Today in the Everton match I noticed that he needs a lot of experience and I think a short loan would be a good option because Gary is comin' back and there are 2 players who can play at right back I mean O'shea and Brown.
So, there is no point in keeping Simmo in the team for the next 6 months.
Don't you agree with me ?

^^ sorry about the language cuz im really dizzy

 

[Jazz 16]

Yes, you may have a point there. Simpson seems a good player but wont really get too many chances at United. I guess a lot depends on what's going to happen with Wes and is Neville going to be the same player he once was. The only people that know these answers are SAF and the people at the club.

We may also be buying a right back or a defender in the transfer window as it has been speculated. If Simpson needs to be loaned out Im sure it will be to Sunderland. Keane trusts him and will play him to gain vital experience. Simpsom played a key role in Sunderland's promotion and it's known that Keane is a great admirer of the player.

 

[Faisal || Red Alert ||]

Yes, you may have a point there. Simpson seems a good player but wont really get too many chances at United. I guess a lot depends on what's going to happen with Wes and is Neville going to be the same player he once was. The only people that know these answers are SAF and the people at the club.

We may also be buying a right back or a defender in the transfer window as it has been speculated. If Simpson needs to be loaned out Im sure it will be to Sunderland. Keane trusts him and will play him to gain vital experience. Simpsom played a key role in Sunderland's promotion and it's known that Keane is a great admirer of the player.

Thanks for taking some time to discuss that ..
there are three points im gonna talk about :

* Gary Neville would never return the EXACTLY SAME player we knew before the injury and thats for sure because the lad is 32 or 33 years old and a 9-month-injury is something serious. He will come back as a great united player with great experience and fantastic abilities, but just not the Gary Neville we knew before.

* I think that Danny Simpson is a hot prospect, but he needs a lot of experience and I think Roy Keane would help with that cuz he know what SAF needs from the lad and he can develop really well under the guidance of Keano ..

* Wes Brown .. I think he will leave soon ( maybe in january ) because the guy is not showing any commitment even in the matches he is not working hard. That's why Sir Alex is giving Simmo the oppurtunity to express him-self to use him at the right back in the absence of Brown ..


Cheers ..

 

[Guest]

?? where did you get the idea that Brown is not working hard? If he didn't show any commitment during trainings/games SAF wouldn't even pick him

 

[Jazz 16]

No problem at all Faisal.

Regarding your first point on Neville, I feel you are quick to make judgements here. Yes Nev has been out a long time but he is our captain, a legend in the making, Red Nev...I feel he has every chance to become as good as he was. He has the drive, hunger and determination to suceed and I believe he will. Im sceptical like the rest but i still believe he can do it.

Your second point I would agree with. it would benefit the lad to play regular football.

Your 3rd point I would have to disagree strongly with that. Wes has always shown his commitment to United over the years with over 270 games for the club.
He has been solid all season in a water tight defence. Its very hard to look good when Rio, Vida and Evra are the other 3 defenders. we all recognise those 3 players are great. but Wes has always done the job when asked.

He is a local lad and the constant speculation over right backs and the re-emergence of Neville/or not can only make him feel unwanted. He has the right to get a good contract, he deserves it. He earns far far less than the top earners and he should get a break imo. We just have to wait and see what happens in January but I would be very sad to see Wes leave.

Btw Wes wasnt absent today. He played centre back in the absence of Rio who had a slight knock.

 

[Faisal || Red Alert ||]

Btw Wes wasnt absent today. He played centre back in the absence of Rio who had a slight knock.

MAN !
I know he played today as a CB.
What I meant is in the future if ferguson decided to sell brown i think simmo would be second choice at right back. Gary will always be our N. 1

....

Guys u got me wrong .. I didnt mean that Brown is bad or even under-performing.
what I meant is that this is not the Brown we knew before. I trust Brown and I have faith in him and I think he can do MUCH better and I really appreciate what he did in the past and I will be sad if he leave the club only I meant that he can do much better because he have the talent and he can do better ..

?? where did you get the idea that Brown is not working hard? If he didn't show any commitment during trainings/games SAF wouldn't even pick him

Thats not what I meant.
I mean Brown can do much better and I think he just need to sign a long term contract at the club. I think that will give him a great boost to perform much better.
I just think he is playing under intense pressure thinkin' of the contract and his future in the club

I hope thats clear enough now guys

 

[red_devils4life]

Yes, you may have a point there. Simpson seems a good player but wont really get too many chances at United. I guess a lot depends on what's going to happen with Wes and is Neville going to be the same player he once was. The only people that know these answers are SAF and the people at the club.

We may also be buying a right back or a defender in the transfer window as it has been speculated. If Simpson needs to be loaned out Im sure it will be to Sunderland. Keane trusts him and will play him to gain vital experience. Simpsom played a key role in Sunderland's promotion and it's known that Keane is a great admirer of the player.

Good post!

 

[mulletsneverdie]

cant agree with the loan out here, he can be cover for evra, as can o'shea, but say wes needs covering, or injuries hit us bad defensively, he's the only natural wing back we have a long with sly. anybody know when sly gets back anyone? keep simmo, he may be inexperienced but he aint gonna get any worse with games, he can do a job, no doubt about that, one poorish game against everton, but we won didnt we

 

[RN10]

We definately do need to loan out simmo, but only when nevilles back! He needs to get more first team experience, because he has the potential to be one hell of a RB