[Guest]

He got all of the big decisions spot on today. Both penalty decisions were correct and so was the sending off.

It's not often a referee is praised, especially after a defeat, but I for one thought he had a very good game.

 

[sunchaser]

He got all of the big decisions spot on today. Both penalty decisions were correct and so was the sending off.

It's not often a referee is praised, especially after a defeat, but I for one thought he had a very good game.

yea he was very good.

still....this is your concern after this defeat ? i couldnt care less tbh

 

[RedForceRising]

We cannot blame the ref at all.

Even the Vidic decision was the correct one. Nemanja just lost his head today.

 

[Guest]

yea he was very good.

still....this is your concern after this defeat ? i couldnt care less tbh

Concern? No I've expressed my concerns in other threads.

 

[christianoharleiro]

yeah agreed, I thought he was very good, missed a few hand balls but they were minor mistakes.

 

[futbol]

He got all of the big decisions spot on today. Both penalty decisions were correct and so was the sending off.

It's not often a referee is praised, especially after a defeat, but I for one thought he had a very good game.

I echo your thoughts. So do Andy Gray and Martin Tyler :wave1:

 

[Mr United]

yea agree with rfr...vidic lost his head today...what a lost

 

[wadadlired]

I agree the ref was good today.

 

[Ady87]

Did anyone see the Liverpool player that completely out stretched Seamen style for a ball that hit his hand and a whistle didn't even go, it's as if play just continued, i couldn't believe my eyes, me and the lads laughed our heads off!

 

[yotix_utd07]

Ouch!

Yeah well, credit to him, he didn't make any dubious decisions other "top class" refs would do.

 

[shiven]

Yeah completely agree!!
He had a good game for a ref in such an important game,
Got every major decision correct..
When a ref has a bad game he's slated, but when he has a good game he's never really praised..

 

[Adam]

He got all of the big decisions spot on today. Both penalty decisions were correct and so was the sending off.

It's not often a referee is praised, especially after a defeat, but I for one thought he had a very good game.

spot on.
just got home and as i was walking up my driveway i was thinking about how long it's been since i watched a big game, with so many big calls and realised that the referee got each spot on.

it's not the result we wanted, but the referee is in no way to blame for that. ran the game well, let it flow although could have extended advantages here or there. got the balance of cards right as well as the big decisions.

 

[sweet fa]

the ref was spot on this downfall was down to the utd players , but they will respond and charge to the title this is a very timely kick up the backside that can only be good for the team in its quest for more silverware .

 

[versa]

He got all of the big decisions spot on today. Both penalty decisions were correct and so was the sending off.

It's not often a referee is praised, especially after a defeat, but I for one thought he had a very good game.

Good thread. We have nobody else on the pitch to praise today. :thumbsup:

 

[Cappy]

Alan Wiley, stand up son, you were MOTM for us. YOU BEAUTY!!!

What a day...:frown:

 

[Jesus Hitler]

yeah fair play he for sure deserves the credit, he had a good game i can have no complaints about him today.. makes you almost want to respect the ref ..... NOT

 

[Cappy]

yeah fair play he for sure deserves the credit, he had a good game i can have no complaints about him today.. makes you almost want to respect the ref ..... NOT

CAN I HAZ SOME RESPECTZ?

 

[Jesus Hitler]

CAN I HAZ SOME RESPECTZ?

ive got more than repspetz for you cappyz

 

[Cappy]

 

[Jay007]

The only thing I would say is that he should have booked Reina for time-wasting. I didn't know if he was booked for the penalty, so if he was that's perhaps why he wasn't.

But he was good, and credit too him. We're quick to criticise referees, so they should get credit when it's deserved as well.