[RoyKeaneIsMagic]

In my personal opinion it has to be a throw up between Bosnich And Van der Sar

 

[manutdc]

VdS for me.

Though for comedy value we always have good ol' Fabien Barthez.

 

[Schmeichel#1]

It's Van Der Sar for me, great goalkeeper who doesn't make stupid mistakes.

 

[MUFC]

VDS has to be the most 'consistent' keeper we've had since Schmeichel's departure however the eccentric Barthez was really good when he was not making those stupid mistakes of his.

 

[azer1990]

well thers no better than schmeichle but it has to be van dar sar we shud of got him straight aftaer schmeicle left. THE GREAT DANE RULES

 

[ImNew2ThisWebsite]

probably van der sar but i always liked howard

 

[Giggs#11]

I would say Edwin van der Sar. He should have been 22.. Superb goalkeeper, just what United needed when they got him..

 

[Loki]

Van Der Sar hands down. Why did we not get him years ago?

 

[Nirk]

Mark Bosnich

 

[danfelixbuffy]

I was a fan of barthezs until he started to make mistakes, twice in a game against deportivo. its got to be vds really,mabey the recent past in tearms of sucess would have been different if we'd have got him much sooner?

 

[mruk]

Barthez was a great keeper and probably the best until he lost the plot and started flapping like a smackhead without his fix
Van der sar feels the most dependable keeper since schmeichel so i'd rather have him than anyone else ... I can't ever see fergie spending mega bucks for a keeper, so hopefully ben foster recovers well from his injury and lives up the promise of the last two seasons ready to take over from VDS

 

[martinutd]

that would be van der sar

 

[1luv1utd]

Easy, Edwin Van Der Sar. We have had good goalkeepers but never of the same calibre as Edwin Van Der Sar, he is a world-class keeper and very solid (apart from the odd mistake) which everyone makes anyway.

 

[david fox]

I think that if his head had'nt been used as a ball then Gary Walsh could have become a great home grown keeper. Are we all forgetting Taibi as consistancy is paramount with a goalie and thats the one thing he had. No seriously it has to be Van der sar for me and i totally agree with missing out on him earlier.

 

[ARBUCKS]

VDS without question!!!

 

[bobthebuilder]

Edwin

 

[johann]

VDS is the one for me

 

[mufc 4ever]

cant decide about the best but the worst is easily carrol

 

[1luv1utd]

Now I think there were worse than Carroll, like Taibi, sticks out in my mind so easily and Ricardo. Ok he hasn't played many games but common if you can't get ahead of a team that has Howard and Carroll and a Dodgy Barthez then you must really suck.

 

[rubberdecky83]

Definitely VDS for consistency and confidence, you never worry when you see him between the sticks. Carroll was alright, Howard was quite good and was unlucky to fall foul of SAF, Barthez was as good as he was unpredictable. Bosnich was a fat mess and Van der Gouw was only ever replacement standard.