Manchester United Talk banner

1 - 20 of 48 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
17 Posts
Seems like he is on his way out anyway even though Strachan has never been the most popular with the Celtic supporters.

As long as it's not going to cost the team a ton... I'd say go for it. What can it hurt? He can play from both sides, he's got some flash, some major wheels, and we are going to need to replace Giggsy at some point.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
115 Posts
He is rather inconsistent. He's a fantastic football in Scotland, but Im not sure if that would translate into success here in England.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
11,551 Posts
I think he could not hack the premiership he may be 1 of the top players in the Scottish league but there are not many good sides apart from Rangers.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
I wouldn't sign him even if we weren't paying him wages.
simply not good enough for United
possibly a mid table side might take him
clearly he has some attitude problems too
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
I cant believe Nani is getting so much stick
I actually think he is going to be a fantastic player for united
He is still a bit light tho needs to fill out.
Both Nani and Park are far better than McGeady.
Trust me the guy is playing in a second rate league
and he doesn't even look class in that.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
15,336 Posts
McGeady is over-rated, thinks hes better than he is, has a massive ego, bad attitude and would be lucky to make it in the Premiership.

So no, I wouldn't sign McGeady.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
25,467 Posts
I actually would sign him if he was on the cheap.
He wasnt voted player of the year in Scotland last season for nothing you know.
The lad plays the game the right way, very attack minded and full of skill.
Not sure if he would definitely be a hit in the Premiership but he has the potential at times.

Ive watched this kid for years for both Ireland and Celtic and he has impressed
a lot (more so for Celtic tbf). He can be a bit inconsistent with his final ball at times
but that could be creased out with some top coaching.

I's actually rate him higher than Park and Nani to be honest.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
9,926 Posts
Jazz 16 said:
I actually would sign him if he was on the cheap.
He wasnt voted player of the year in Scotland last season for nothing you know.
The lad plays the game the right way, very attack minded and full of skill.
Not sure if he would definitely be a hit in the Premiership but he has the potential at times.

Ive watched this kid for years for both Ireland and Celtic and he has impressed
a lot (more so for Celtic tbf). He can be a bit inconsistent with his final ball at times
but that could be creased out with some top coaching.

I's actually rate him higher than Park and Nani to be honest.

Not much harder to be rated higher then Nni now TBH :p lol




I wouldn't be inclined to sign him. We all know that Fergie was interested a few
seasons ago, but I simply don't see how he'd get a place in our team. He wastes
an incredible amount of possession at times, although he does have bags of skill
an ability. On the International stage, he's been a real, real disappointment IMO.
Can't really recall any great performances from him for Ireland, and with players
like Duff and Ireland in the squad, Trapp may find it hard to fit him into it.

Then comes our team, do you really think he could get into a wingers position
with the following players ahead of you in the pecking order?

  • Ronaldo
  • Giggs
  • Park
  • Fletcher
  • Hargreaves (When fit:rolleyes:)

If we did end up getting him;

  1. He'd be a waste of money for anything above £10M IMO
  2. He'd have to settle as a back-up player
  3. Have much less of a chance of getting into the International squad as he
    wouldn't be playing as much.
I know he's gonna he on his way out of Glasgow soon, but TBH, its Scottish football
he's playing in, where theres only really 3 maybe 4 good teams and then Rangers
and Celtic are ahead of them and they're no world beaters either, although I'd say
both would do nicely in the Premier League.



But as for McGeady signing for United, its a no, no, no from me :D



..



manutd004 said:
McGeady is over-rated.....has a massive ego...
I would be inclined to agree...


.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,358 Posts
Jazz 16 said:
I actually would sign him if he was on the cheap.
He wasnt voted player of the year in Scotland last season for nothing you know.
The lad plays the game the right way, very attack minded and full of skill.
Not sure if he would definitely be a hit in the Premiership but he has the potential at times.

Ive watched this kid for years for both Ireland and Celtic and he has impressed
a lot (more so for Celtic tbf). He can be a bit inconsistent with his final ball at times
but that could be creased out with some top coaching.

I's actually rate him higher than Park and Nani to be honest.
Is this a sick joke Jazz?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
25,467 Posts
Berbatov08 said:
Is this a sick joke Jazz?
Which part?
He was scintillating last season and he is still a young lad.
Park and Nani are hardly world class now are they?
Im not saying McGeady is, cos he isnt, but he has shown more in his career thus far than Nani has.
And as much as I love Park you wont see him leaving defenders for dead like McGeady does.
All Im saying is that signing McGeady would be an option considering we dont have
too much strength and depth on the left. But I guess it will be irrelevant if
Tosic arrives and proves to be worthy. Ronaldo aside, do you really think our
wingers are world class and United standard?
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
27,712 Posts
Keano! said:
  1. Have much less of a chance of getting into the International squad as he
    wouldn't be playing as much.



.

doesnt stop glejnn whelan been no one on the starting team evrytime for us :p r gibson for that matter:rolleyes:

but seriously im going to have to agree with jazz if we can get him for cheap we could get ourselfs an absoloute gem! he rough around the edges and abit incossisent but when you think of park and nani id rather have mcgeady any day of the week!

he won not only young player of the year in scotland last year but player of the year too( i think)! were not blessed with left wingers as giggsy isnt a winger anymore and nani blows hot and cold! he can also play both wings witch shows his verstiaitly! he would be working with an amazing coach in sir alex probably the best in the world! he reminsds me of ronaldo in his 1st season could do things with the ball that others could only dream of yet his final ball let him down! and i know people will say that ronaldo was 18 mcgeadys 23 but whos to say hes not a fast devolper? hesworth a try when u think nani cost 17 million

under 10 mill i say buy him
over 10 mill dont buy him!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
542 Posts
no no no no no :((((( buy someone decent!

DAVID SIlva would destroy this guy

Joaquín would just **** on this guy open ur eyes people ffs
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
27,712 Posts
forzaunited said:
no no no no no :((((( buy someone decent!

DAVID SIlva would destroy this guy

Joaquín would just **** on this guy open ur eyes people ffs

deacent?? theres a reason why this guy is the best player in the scotish league and ur sitting on your arse behind a computer screen slating him the reason is he is deacent!

there is bettr players out there no doubt but if we did sign him it wouldnt be that bad hed be better than park!if he comes cheap he has thechance to be a great signing
 
1 - 20 of 48 Posts
Top